Solution selling: a one-page problem brief to copy

Solution selling builds the offer from the buyer’s problem. Copy a one-page problem brief and check it on real calls with a simple three-level rubric.

Solution selling is an approach led by the buyer's problem: the offer is built from that problem before any product is described. Below is a one-page problem brief you can copy, fill in during discovery and check against the recording of the call.

The guide covers the short history of the method, the call flow we work with at Triple Session, the brief with a check for each field, the limit the Harvard Business Review put on solution selling in 2012 and a way to train a sales team on it. If you are still picking a method, start with our guide to how to choose a sales methodology and come back.

What is solution selling?

Wikipedia describes solution selling as problem-led, as opposed to product-led. Mike Bosworth founded a training organization called Solution Selling, and his book, Solution Selling: Creating Buyers in Difficult Selling Markets, came out from McGraw-Hill in the mid 1990s. Keith Eades later wrote The New Solution Selling, also with McGraw-Hill. Wikipedia also credits Frank Watts with the process, so the origin is disputed. You will also see the name written as solutions selling, and it means the same thing.

This guide does not describe the steps or terms of Bosworth's book. The call flow in the next section is our own flow, and the problem brief is our own format. Read the book for the original method; the rest of this guide gives you a version your team can run next week.

In our own breakdown of the types of selling, the line between solution selling and consultative selling is the proposal. Both begin with a diagnosis. Solution selling then builds the offer from parts, and each part has to answer something the buyer said.

How does solution selling work on a call?

This is our flow, in four phases:

  • Diagnose. Ask about the problem until the buyer has described it in their own words, including what it costs them.
  • Repeat it back. Say the problem and the cost in the buyer's words, and wait for a correction.
  • Build the offer. Pick only the parts of your product that act on that problem.
  • Check each part. For every part you propose, find the sentence the buyer said that it answers. A part with no sentence behind it comes out.

Here is the flow with a made-up company. Fennick Payroll, a fictional payroll software company, sells to a dental group, and every figure below is invented for the example. The buyer says that every second Friday two people on the finance team spend an afternoon fixing timesheet errors before payroll can run, because each clinic sends timesheets in a different format. The salesperson repeats it back: two people, one afternoon, every two weeks, caused by mixed formats. The buyer agrees and adds that a late payroll has already cost them a complaint from staff.

The offer that follows has two parts: a timesheet import that accepts each clinic's format, and an approval step before the run. The benefits module and the tax filing add-on stay out of the proposal, because the buyer said nothing those parts would answer. They can come back later if the buyer raises them.

If you want a worked example of a solution sale in another industry, see our selling examples. For a step-by-step version of discovery itself, see needs based selling.

The problem brief: a template to copy

The brief turns the flow into a document: a single page with seven fields that the seller fills in during the call or right after it. Copy the block below into your CRM or your playbook.

PROBLEM BRIEF
Account:            Date:            Filled in by:

(a) The problem, in the buyer's words
    Write the sentence the buyer said, as close to word for word as you can.

(b) Who feels it and who pays
    Name the role that lives with the problem and the role that signs.

(c) The cost, in the buyer's number
    Write the figure the buyer gave, with their unit (hours, money, deals).
    If they gave none, write "no number given" and leave it open.

(d) If nothing changes, what happens and when
    Write the consequence the buyer described and the date or period.

(e) The event that forces a date
    A launch, a renewal, an audit, a hire. Write what the buyer named.

(f) What the buyer already tried
    List each earlier attempt and why it fell short, in the buyer's words.

(g) The proposal, line by line
    One line per part of the offer. Next to each line, write the letter of
    the field it answers. A line with no letter comes out of the proposal.

Field (g) is the center of the brief. It forces the proposal to be assembled from the problem, and it gives the manager one thing to check on the recording: for each part of the offer, was there a sentence from the buyer behind it?

How do you check that the brief is filled in well?

A brief can be full and still be weak, so the manager checks it against the recording of the call. The rule is that a field only counts when the buyer can be heard saying it. The three levels below are our own, applied to each field.

FieldSolidThinEmpty
(a) ProblemThe buyer's own sentence, quotedA summary in the salesperson's wordsA product need ("they want a better tool")
(b) Who feels it, who paysTwo roles, both namedOne role namedOnly a company name
(c) CostA figure from the buyer, with a unitA vague size ("a lot of time")No cost discussed
(d) If nothing changesA consequence and a periodA consequence with no periodNot asked
(e) Forcing eventAn event the buyer named, with a dateAn event the salesperson assumedNone
(f) Already triedAt least one attempt and why it failedAn attempt with no reasonNot asked
(g) ProposalEvery line points to a fieldMost lines point to a fieldLines copied from a standard package

A brief with two or more Empty fields means discovery is unfinished, so the next step is another conversation with the buyer. If you already score calls, you can add these seven fields as criteria; our guide to sales call scoring covers how to build the scorecard.

How is solution selling different from consultative, value and Challenger selling?

Each of these has its own sources, so we point to them and skip a summary here. What follows is where each one meets the brief.

  • Consultative selling. Same diagnosis, different proposal. See the types of selling for how we place the two side by side.
  • Value selling. A separate method that this guide does not describe. The nearest point in the brief is field (c), where the cost goes down in the buyer's own words.
  • Challenger selling. It has its own guide: the Challenger Sale. It is the one to read when the buyer arrives with a fixed specification, the case the next section raises.
  • SPIN selling. Built on Neil Rackham's analysis of more than 35,000 calls in 23 countries. Our guide to SPIN selling covers the question sequence, and the full list of methods is in our sales methodologies overview.

When does solution selling stop working?

In "The End of Solution Sales", published in the Harvard Business Review in July and August 2012, Adamson, Dixon and Toman argue that solution selling worked when the customer understood the problem but did not know how to solve it. By their account, the buying company can now define the solution for itself, because its procurement teams have grown more sophisticated and purchasing consultants bring troves of data.

For the brief, this changes how you read field (a). When the buyer arrives with a specification, write it down as given, and then treat field (a) as a question: what sits behind this specification? The buyer's answer becomes the problem sentence, and fields (b) to (f) follow from it. We read only the summary and the opening lines on the HBR page, so read the full article before leaning on it for more.

How do you train a sales team on it?

Three steps, in this order:

  1. Put the brief in your CRM as seven fields. A field that exists in the CRM gets asked about. Keep field (g) as a text field with the letters in it.
  2. Watch two sessions together. From the Triple Session library, the description of the 5-minute session How to Perform a World Class Discovery Call says it breaks down the elements of the solution selling and consultative selling models. The description of the 4-minute session How to Nail a Sales Demo says it recommends focusing on the two or three features that attack the customer's problem and asking whether each one is relevant. We quote only those public descriptions. Each feature you show should point to a field in the brief, whatever the number.
  3. Have the manager check three calls a week with the table above. Three a week is our own suggestion and has no measurement behind it. Pick the field that comes out Thin or Empty on the most briefs and coach that one first.

The free course Presenting a Solution is a good next step for the demo part.

Where to start

Take your last discovery call, copy the brief and fill it in from the recording. Mark each field Solid, Thin or Empty, and look at field (g): how many lines of your proposal point to a field? The fields that came out Thin or Empty are the questions to ask on the next call.

Frequently asked questions

Who created solution selling?

Mike Bosworth founded a training organization called Solution Selling and wrote the book Solution Selling: Creating Buyers in Difficult Selling Markets, published by McGraw-Hill in the mid 1990s. Keith Eades later wrote The New Solution Selling. Wikipedia also credits Frank Watts with the process, so the origin is disputed.

What is the difference between solution selling and consultative selling?

In our reading, both start with a diagnosis of the buyer's problem. The difference is the proposal: in solution selling the offer is assembled from parts, and each part has to answer something the buyer said. A one-page problem brief makes that link visible, because every line of the offer points to a field.

Is solution selling outdated?

Adamson, Dixon and Toman argued in the Harvard Business Review in 2012 that solution selling worked when the customer understood the problem but not how to solve it, and that, with increasingly sophisticated procurement teams and purchasing consultants armed with data, companies can now define solutions for themselves. Our answer is to keep the diagnosis and start from what the buyer already specified, asking what sits behind it.

Is solution selling the same as value selling?

They are separate methods with separate sources, and this guide does not describe value selling. The nearest point in our brief is the cost field, where the salesperson records the cost in the buyer's own words.

Sources

não é MDX válido, remover antes do PR. FAQ: 4 perguntas, repetidas no corpo como no molde. CTA: calculadora de call scoring (recurso já usado em outros posts), sem oferta de produto. Contagem de palavras do corpo (sem metadata, sem este bloco): cerca de 1.990. Sem H1; 10 H2 (What is solution selling, How does it work on a call, brief template, How do you check, difference from consultative/value/Challenger, When does it stop working, train a team, Where to start, FAQ, Sources). -->

See your team's calls scored on your playbook.

Send a few recordings. We score them and show where each person can improve. No cost, no contract.