Sell me this pen: how to answer it and how to score it

Sell me this pen is a sales interview test. Ask two questions, sum up the answer, then ask for the sale. Managers get four checks to score it on a call.

Sell me this pen is a sales interview test: someone hands you a pen and asks you to sell it. A strong answer starts with questions about the person, and the pen comes up only after you know what that person needs.

This guide gives candidates four steps to answer it. It also gives managers four yes-or-no checks, one per step, to score the answer in an interview or in a practice round with your team. Adapt both to the role you hire for.

What is "sell me this pen" testing?

The test asks whether a person starts with the buyer or with the product. Someone who answers by listing what the pen does has opened with a pitch. Someone who asks what the pen is for has made the opening move of discovery, the part of a sales conversation where the seller learns what the buyer needs.

Neil Rackham's SPIN Selling (1995) rests on research that its publisher describes as more than 35,000 calls by 10,000 salespeople in 23 countries over 12 years. Two of its chapters are titled "Investigating: questions and sales success" and "Obtaining commitment: closing the sale," the same order the answer below follows: questions first and a request for commitment last. Our post on SPIN selling covers the framework, and sales frameworks shows where it sits next to other methods.

For a wider path into sales roles, see our guide on how to learn sales.

How do you answer "sell me this pen" step by step?

Treat the interviewer as a buyer who has told you nothing yet. The table sets a weak answer next to a strong one at each step, and the short sections under it explain what the step does.

StepWeak answerStrong answer
1. Ask two questions first"This is a smooth, reliable pen with a comfortable grip.""Before I tell you about it, when do you usually write by hand?" The interviewer answers, "Mostly when I sign forms." Then: "What is the most annoying part of signing a stack of forms with the pen you have now?"
2. Sum up in their words"Okay, got it. So, about this pen.""So you sign a stack of forms most mornings, and your current pen skips when you go fast. Did I get that right?"
3. Tie the pen to one problem"It has a gel tip and a metal clip, and it comes in six colors.""You said the skipping costs you time on those forms. This pen is built to keep up with fast writing, so that part goes away."
4. Ask for the decision"So yeah, that's the pen." or "Let me know what you think.""Do you want to take it, or would you rather test it on tomorrow's stack first?"

Step 1: ask two questions before you describe the pen

The first question opens the topic and the second builds on the answer. The 9-minute session Discovery Linking Questions describes this move on its public page as taking the information from one answer and making it the focus of your next question.

There is research behind the habit of asking. Huang, Yeomans, Brooks, Minson and Gino (2017) reported in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology that people who ask more questions are better liked by the people they talk with. In their account the effect runs through the asker seeming responsive to what the other person said, and in speed-dating conversations the people who asked more questions were more likely to get a partner's agreement to a second date. The authors also report that people do not anticipate this effect. These were studies of live conversations between people, and sales was not their setting, so treat the result as a reason to try the habit and watch what happens on your own calls. For a longer treatment of buyer questions, see needs-based selling.

Step 2: sum up what you heard in their words

Say back the interviewer's own words and end with a question. The ending question matters as much as the summary, because a correction gives you something you did not know a few seconds ago. A summary in your own words, such as "so you need a premium writing instrument," swaps the buyer's problem for your pitch.

Step 3: tie the pen to one problem they named

Pick one problem from the summary and link the pen to it in about one sentence. A feature the buyer never mentioned connects to nothing the buyer said. If the interviewer gives you room, add one question about what the problem costs the buyer before you make the link. The 12-minute session Discovery Implications covers the role of implications in discovery.

Step 4: ask for the decision or an agreed next step

End with a question that asks for the purchase or offers a next step. Rackham's chapter title "Obtaining commitment: closing the sale" names this step. A plain question is enough to ask for the sale, and two options let the buyer pick. After "let me know what you think," the buyer decides when the conversation ends.

What do you do if the interviewer gives you nothing to work with?

If the interviewer answers "I never use pens" or "I would not buy one," treat that as information about the buyer and ask another question: "Fair enough. What do you write notes on, and what annoys you about it?" Defending the pen at that moment shows that you pitch first, and a new question keeps you in discovery.

Pushback that comes after the pitch is a different skill. Our post on how to practice sales objection handling covers it.

How does a manager score a "sell me this pen" answer?

Fix the setup before the interview so every candidate faces the same buyer. Hand over the same pen and prepare one short answer for each question. Keep one pushback line ready as well, such as "I never use pens." Then listen for four things and answer each with yes or no:

  1. Did the person ask two questions about you before describing the pen?
  2. Did the summary reuse your words and end with a question that let you correct it?
  3. Did the person link the pen to a problem you named, in about one sentence?
  4. Did the person end with a question asking for the purchase or an agreed next step?

Write down what counts as a pass before you start, so every candidate is scored the same way. Four yeses means the person ran the whole method. The checks cover the first minutes of a conversation, and a real discovery call runs much longer, so use them as a screen and then listen to real calls. Our post on sales call scoring shows how to build a scorecard from yes-or-no lines like these.

How do you practice it with your team?

Run it as a five-minute role play with three people. One person plays the buyer and keeps the prepared answers, and another plays the seller. The third holds the four checks and reads out the yes or no after the round. Rotate the roles, then change the object. A water bottle or a stapler works as well as the pen, because the checks apply to any product.

After each round the scorer names the first check that came out as no, and the seller repeats that step once. Keeping the practice on one step at a time makes it easy to see what changed. For a scripted scene with lines for both sides, see our sales role play script. For more ways to practice on your own, see how to learn sales and how to practice sales objection handling.

Where to go next

For a full discovery conversation with commentary, read sales talk examples, and for examples across sale types, see selling examples. The free course Discovery Best Practices describes itself as teaching you to ask the right questions, listen carefully and make discovery calls more successful. The 13-minute session Five Powerful Sales Questions That Guide Prospects Without Pressure presents a five-question framework that runs from the opening of a conversation to a pitch the buyer has agreed to hear.

Sources

See your team's calls scored on your playbook.

Send a few recordings. We score them and show where each person can improve. No cost, no contract.