Consultative selling: a 6-check call rubric

Consultative selling explained, with a six-check rubric that shows whether a call was consultative or a pitch, plus lines to say and the mistakes to avoid.

Consultative selling is an approach where the seller acts as an advisor: they diagnose the buyer's problem with questions, then recommend only what fits. You can tell whether a call was consultative by six checks, listed below.

This post covers what consultative selling (also called consultative sales) means, where the idea comes from and what the sources say, then a six-check rubric you can mark on a call transcript, a scored example and the cases where the approach is the wrong choice. It ends with coaching and AI tools. The rubric is ours, built from the sources named below. No author published it.

What is consultative selling?

In a consultative call, the seller's job is to learn what is wrong on the buyer's side before saying anything about the product. Questions come first. The seller then recommends the part of the offer that matches what the buyer said, and says so plainly when nothing matches.

Pitch-first selling reverses the order. The seller leads with the product, and questions serve to find a moment to use it. Both styles can sound friendly, but the order of events differs, and that can be checked. At the far end of pitch-first sits high-pressure selling, which we cover separately.

Our guide to sales methodologies places this approach next to the others, and needs-based selling goes deeper on discovery.

Where does consultative selling come from?

Four sources sit behind the approach. The first is named for the history, and the other three each add one piece to the rubric below.

  • Mack Hanan wrote a book titled Consultative Selling. We name it as a place to start reading and take nothing from it for the rubric.
  • Neil Rackham wrote SPIN Selling (McGraw-Hill, 1988). The description of the Routledge edition says his team studied more than 35,000 sales calls made by 10,000 salespeople in 23 countries over 12 years, and that methods built for low-value sales often fail in major ones. Rackham has described the gain at Huthwaite as coming from the whole coaching process: each seller had a baseline call and five calls with coaching, and managers were trained to code the calls. In his words, "it wasn't the four little questions".
  • Mahan Khalsa wrote Let's Get Real or Let's Not Play (Franklin Covey, 1999). Randy Illig is a coauthor of the 2008 Portfolio edition, and that edition's description says salespeople do better when they focus on helping the customer succeed, for example by helping to cut costs, grow revenue and improve productivity, quality and satisfaction.
  • Dixon and Adamson wrote The Challenger Sale (Portfolio, 2011). Their study of thousands of salespeople sorted them into five profiles, and the Challenger profile was the only one that delivered consistently high performance.

Read together, they give the rubric its parts: the question checks draw on Rackham's SPIN method, the focus on cost from Khalsa and Illig, and Dixon and Adamson's finding is our reason to treat recommending as part of the job. That is why check 5 asks for a specific recommendation and check 6 for a next step. For the Challenger view in full, see our post on The Challenger Sale.

How can you tell a consultative call from a pitch?

Mark the words on the transcript, because a manager can play a line back in a 1:1. Our post on coaching sales techniques makes the same point about size: "consultative selling" as a term is too big to check on a call, while one question, such as what the problem costs the buyer's team, is small enough.

Each check gets one of three marks:

  • Met (2 points): the line is on the transcript, and when it is a question, the buyer answered it.
  • Partly met (1 point): something close is there, but it is weaker than the criterion.
  • Missed (0 points): nothing on the transcript matches.

A call can score 0 to 12. The total matters less than which check is the first below "met", because that is the one to coach.

The six-check consultative call rubric

Each check has four parts: the criterion, a line that passes, a line that fails and a rule for marking. Checks 1 to 4 draw on Rackham's question method (see our post on SPIN Selling), and the checks as a whole draw on the public description of the session 7 Consultative Selling Strategies to Close the Deal, which mentions opening with a view of the industry, assessing fit and a next step confirmed on the calendar. That page does not list the seven strategies, so we treat it as a source of ideas and write our own lines.

1. Opens on the buyer's situation

The seller's first questions are about the buyer's business and use something the seller learned before the call.

  • Passes: "I saw you opened a second depot in the spring. How are routes split between the two now?"
  • Fails: "Let me start by telling you a bit about us."
  • Mark: Met if the first question after the greeting is about the buyer's business, shows research and gets an answer. Partly met if it is about the buyer but generic, such as "tell me about your company", which research could have answered, or if it is specific and the buyer does not answer it. Missed if the seller talks about themselves or the product first.

2. Asks about the problem before the feature

The seller asks what is hard or broken today, with no product feature named in the question.

  • Passes: "What happens when a customer changes an order after the routes are drawn?"
  • Fails: "Do you need route optimization?"
  • Mark: Met if at least one question asks about a difficulty and the buyer describes one. Partly met if the problem is raised only through a feature name, so the buyer can answer yes or no. Missed if the product comes up before any question about a difficulty.

3. Asks what the problem costs

The seller asks for the consequence in time or money, and the buyer answers in their own terms. This is the check Khalsa and Illig's focus on cost points to.

  • Passes: "When a driver doubles back, what does that cost you in a typical week?"
  • Fails: "That sounds frustrating."
  • Mark: Met if the seller asks for a cost or consequence and the buyer gives one. Partly met if the seller asks only whether the problem is a big one. Missed if the problem is never tied to a cost.

4. Gets the buyer to say the need in their own words

The buyer states what fixing the problem would be worth, in the buyer's own words.

  • Passes: "If route changes took minutes, what would that change for your team?"
  • Fails: "So what you need is faster route changes, right?"
  • Mark: Met if the buyer states the value and the seller did not. Partly met if the seller states the need and the buyer only agrees. Missed if no need is stated before the recommendation.

5. Recommends only the part that fits, or says it is not a fit

The recommendation points back to what the buyer said, and it leaves something out. When nothing fits, saying so counts as a pass.

  • Passes: "From what you described, only the route-change piece matters to you, so I would leave the reporting out for now."
  • Fails: "Let me show you everything we do."
  • Mark: Met if the recommendation names the buyer's problem and drops at least one part of the offer, or the seller says the offer is not a fit. Partly met if it is tied to the problem but comes with a full tour. Missed if the seller gives the standard demo. A story about a comparable customer belongs here, as proof for the part you recommended.

6. Ends with a next step on the calendar

A specific date and time are set before the call ends, and the invite goes to the people who need to be there.

  • Passes: "Let's book Thursday at 10, and I'll send the invite now so your dispatch lead can join."
  • Fails: "I'll send some information and we'll circle back."
  • Mark: Met if a specific date and time are agreed and the invite is sent or named on the call with the attendees who need to be there. Partly met if a specific date and time are agreed but no invite is sent or named, or the attendees are left open. Missed if no specific date and time are agreed, which includes "next week" and "I'll send some information".

What does a scored call look like?

This is a fictional example. Alder Route, a delivery-planning software company, and Pinecrest Linen, a laundry service that delivers to restaurants, are invented for this post, and no real call is shown. Maya sells for Alder Route, and Dana runs operations at Pinecrest.

CheckWhat happened on the callMarkPoints
1. SituationMaya: "I saw Pinecrest added a second depot this spring. How are routes split between the two now?" Dana: "By hand, mostly. One of us redraws them every morning."Met2
2. ProblemMaya: "What goes wrong when a restaurant changes an order after the routes are drawn?" Dana: "Drivers double back."Met2
3. CostMaya: "Is that a big problem for you?" Dana: "It's annoying."Partly met1
4. Need in their wordsMaya: "So what you need is faster route changes, right?" Dana: "I guess."Partly met1
5. FitMaya walks through routing, the driver app, reporting and invoicing.Missed0
6. Next stepMaya: "I'll email a summary and we'll talk next week."Missed0

The call scores 6 of 12. The first check below "met" is check 3, so that is the one to coach. The call also shows why the order matters: Maya never learned the cost, so she had nothing to build checks 4 and 5 on. A rewrite of the check 3 line is "What does a redrawn route cost you in a typical week?"

How does consultative selling help close a deal?

It moves the close into checks 4, 5 and 6, so closing deals needs no separate technique. By the time the seller recommends, the buyer has already said what the problem costs and what fixing it is worth. The recommendation then answers the buyer's own words, and the next step on the calendar keeps the deal moving.

If you want a guide to closing deals the consultative way, mark your next calls and look at where they stop:

  • Calls that miss check 4 have no need in the buyer's words, so the recommendation has nothing to answer.
  • Calls that miss check 5 hand the buyer a full tour, and the buyer must find the relevant part alone.
  • Calls that miss check 6 leave nothing for the next conversation to start from.

The public description of the session on consultative strategies also lists a next step confirmed on the calendar.

When is consultative selling the wrong approach?

It is the wrong approach when the buyer has nothing to diagnose. The Routledge description of Rackham's book says methods built for selling low-value goods often fail in major sales. That sentence is about those methods, so it is only a hint for us. Our read is that consultative selling suits larger purchases, and that six checks is too much call for a small one.

ScenarioWhat the buyer wantsOur read
A simple, low-cost purchaseA fast answer on price and deliverySkip most of the rubric and keep checks 5 and 6. See transactional selling.
A buyer who already knows what they wantConfirmation that your product fitsStart at check 5. Return to checks 2 and 3 only if the buyer's list seems to miss the real problem.
A long cycle with several people involvedEach person's own problem handledRun checks 2 to 4 once for each person. See relationship selling.

Which mistakes turn a consultative call into a pitch?

Each mistake below is a check that was skipped, so the fix is the same as the check.

  • Asking situation questions the buyer's website answers (check 1). Do the research first, then ask about what you could not find.
  • Jumping from the problem to the demo (checks 3 and 4). Stop after the problem and ask what it costs.
  • Naming the need for the buyer (check 4). Ask what fixing it would change, and wait.
  • Asking good questions and recommending nothing specific (check 5). An advisor with no opinion is still only a question-asker. Pick the part that fits and say why.
  • Ending with "let me know" (check 6). Book the time before the call ends.

How do you coach this across a sales team?

Mark three calls per person with the rubric, then coach one check at a time. This is our recommendation, with no measured number behind it. Three calls give you something to compare, so a miss that repeats stands out.

Each 1:1 covers one check out of the six. Play the moment on the call where the check should have happened, agree on the line the person will try next, and check it on their next calls. Have two managers mark the same call every so often. If their marks differ, the wording of the criterion needs work.

The Huthwaite description of Rackham's study is the reason to coach on real calls: the gain he describes came from baseline and coached calls with trained managers. For a fuller look at turning a technique into one checkable step, see coaching sales techniques and call coaching. For building the scorecard that holds the six checks, see sales call scoring.

Can AI tools help with consultative selling?

They can help if they show their evidence. All six checks are visible in the words of a call, so a tool that transcribes calls can in principle be asked about each one. The question to ask is what the tool shows for each mark.

When you look at any tool for this, check four things:

  1. It shows the line from the call behind every mark, so a manager can play it back.
  2. You can write the six checks as your own criteria, with your own passing and failing lines.
  3. Two managers can compare their marks with the tool's marks on the same call.
  4. It gives a mark for each check, since a single "consultative score" gives a manager nothing to coach.

Read a sample of the marks yourself before trusting the rest.

Where should you start?

Take your next three calls and mark only check 3, the cost of the problem. Count how many of them have a line where the seller asked what the problem costs and the buyer answered. If the count is below three, that is your first coaching topic.

See your team's calls scored on your playbook.

Send a few recordings. We score them and show where each person can improve. No cost, no contract.